Choosing The Right Ecommerce Platform

*Updated on 9/24/24

Your website is like your brand's online smile – it’s usually the first thing people see, making it crucial for your site to be both professional and easy to navigate. An ecommerce website not only showcases your products and services to a broader audience but also helps establish trust and credibility with prospective customers.

Forbes.com reports that the global ecommerce market is expected to be worth $6.3 trillion this year.

What does that mean, you ask?

When it comes to choosing the right ecommerce platform, everything!

It’s a big deal because it can really make or break your business. You want to make sure that as your business gets bigger, your platform can handle it without any hiccups, and that your customers have a smooth time shopping on your site.

Person exploring ecommerce platform features on laptop, representing business success with digital agency ecommerce solutions

What is an Ecommerce Platform?

An ecommerce platform is a comprehensive software solution that enables businesses to build, manage, and operate an online store. It's where you keep track of what you've got in stock, take payments, and chat with customers. It's the one place where everything about your online store comes together, making sure things like advertising and shipping work like a charm.

Selecting the right ecommerce platform should be based on factors such as business size, industry, and future growth aspirations. A platform that aligns with a company's current needs and potential expansion plans can significantly impact its success. For small businesses or startups, a scalable solution that grows with the business is essential, while larger enterprises may require a more robust and customizable platform to handle high volumes of transactions and complex operations.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing an Ecommerce Platform

There are several key factors businesses should take into account when choosing an ecommerce platform:

  • Ease of use is important to simplify daily operations and reduce the learning curve for employees.
  • Customization options allow businesses to tailor the platform to their unique brand identity and customer experience requirements.
  • Integration capabilities are vital for seamless connections with existing systems like inventory management, CRM, and marketing tools.
  • Robust security features are essential to protect sensitive customer data and maintain trust.
  • Cost considerations should include not only the initial investment but also ongoing expenses related to maintenance, upgrades, and transaction fees.

Scalability

Scalability is crucial, as the platform must support future business expansion without performance issues. This is especially important when it comes to enterprise businesses. It allows those businesses to manage big jumps in traffic during busy times and easily accommodate expanded product lines and customer numbers as the business expands.

  • Magento (now Adobe Commerce) allows you to scale your business with large inventory sizes. It does not have limits to adding products; you can add hundreds of thousands of products.
  • Shopify offers opportunities for businesses seeking to grow and expand internationally by upgrading to Shopify Plus. This premium option allows businesses to operate multiple storefronts.
  • BigCommerce enables effortless expansion of brands, geographies, and sales channels with distinct storefronts, and you can manage them from a single account, achieve greater scalability, and deliver personalized experiences for any audience, region, or segment.
  • OroCommerce’s multi-tenant architecture enables the management of multiple businesses and websites from a single system. This setup simplifies operations and supports scalability, allowing for the handling of millions of SKUs and seamless expansion without resource issues.
  • Salesforce Commerce Cloud is highly scalable, thanks to its cloud-based architecture and multitenant platform, ensuring seamless performance even during peak traffic periods, allowing businesses to manage global operations efficiently without compromising on performance.
  • ROC Commerce is designed with scalability in mind, enabling businesses to expand their digital presence seamlessly as they grow. This adaptability is critical for both B2B and B2C marketplaces.

Flexibility and Customization

Customization is crucial for businesses aiming to meet their unique needs, and the choice between open-source and hosted platforms plays a significant role in this decision.

Open-source platforms like Adobe Commerce and OroCommerce offer exceptional flexibility due to their open codebases, so businesses can modify and tailor every aspect of their online stores to fit precise requirements. This level of customization is ideal for companies with specific demands and the technical resources to implement them.

Hosted platforms such as Shopify, BigCommerce, and Salesforce Commerce Cloud provide a more user-friendly experience with built-in features and support, which can streamline operations for businesses without extensive technical teams. However, these platforms often have limitations in customization due to their closed ecosystems.

The trade-off between flexibility and ease of use means that businesses must carefully consider their specific needs, resources, and technical capabilities when selecting a platform to ensure it aligns with their strategic goals.

Industry Suitability

When it comes to ecommerce platforms, some cater to B2B and others to B2C or hybrid models:

  • OroCommerce stands out in B2B, with customizable workflows and robust integration capabilities that allow businesses to tailor their operations to specific industry needs for better efficiency and customer satisfaction.
  • ROC Commerce excels in complex ecommerce environments, providing the flexibility that’s ideal for both B2B and B2C models. Its scalable architecture and advanced personalization options allows companies to seamlessly navigate diverse customer demands and market conditions.
  • Salesforce Commerce Cloud is a top choice for large and enterprise B2C brands, with a comprehensive suite of tools designed for superior customer engagement. Its scalability and ability to deliver seamless omnichannel experiences make it ideal for brands looking to create cohesive and engaging customer journeys across all touchpoints.

Cost and Pricing Structure

There are a number of factors that must be considered to understand the total cost of ownership for each ecommerce platform. Subscription-based platforms like Shopify, BigCommerce, and Salesforce typically offer predictable pricing with monthly or annual fees that cover hosting, security, and updates. They may include additional transaction fees and costs for third-party integrations.

Custom solutions like ROC Commerce and OroCommerce, and open-source platforms like Adobe Commerce, often include initial setup costs and custom development fees. In addition, they provide tailored features and scalability without the recurring fees associated with subscription models.

Performance and Security

Shopify, BigCommerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud, ROC Commerce, OroCommerce, and open-source solutions such as Adobe Commerce prioritize fast load times, secure payment processing, and adherence to industry standards.

Fast load times are important for reducing bounce rates and improving customer satisfaction, while secure payment processing ensures that sensitive customer information is protected against fraud and breaches. When shopping online, users want to know their credit card details are safe. That's where things like PCI DSS come in. It's a set of rules that ecommerce sites follow to keep payment info secure. Plus, they use SSL certificates for data protection. It’s like putting data in a safe when it's sent over the internet, so no one else can peek at it.

It’s not just about keeping card details safe. These websites also have to keep up with the latest security updates and make sure that when a user logs in, it's really that person. That's why they may ask for a password or send a code to the user’s phone. It's all about making sure personal info stays private.

Key Features to Look For in an Ecommerce Platform

There are some distinct “must-have” features for any ecommerce platform.

Seamless Mobile Experience

A seamless mobile shopping experience is a must for ecommerce success. Mobile-friendly designs and responsive templates ensure that ecommerce sites are accessible and visually appealing across all devices, reducing bounce rates and increasing conversion rates.

Platforms like Shopify and BigCommerce provide built-in responsive design capabilities that automatically adjust the site's layout to fit various screen sizes. These platforms also provide mobile optimization tools that streamline navigation and speed up load times.

SEO and Marketing Tools

Your ecommerce platform must include SEO optimization, email marketing, and social media integration. These are key components that enable businesses to effectively attract and engage with their target audience.

Platforms like BigCommerce are known for their robust SEO capabilities, offering features such as customizable URLs, automatic sitemaps, and built-in analytics tools that help improve their search engine rankings. Salesforce Commerce Cloud has advanced marketing tools for personalized email campaigns, targeted promotions, and seamless social media integrations.

Multi-Channel Integration

It's important to be where your customers are; that means not just sticking to your website, but popping up on different places. By selling across various platforms such as social media and online marketplaces, businesses can tap into diverse customer bases and improve their brand visibility. That's where Shopify and Salesforce Commerce Cloud come in handy.

These platforms are like the behind-the-scenes magicians that make it possible for businesses to show up on all these different platforms without losing their minds trying to keep track of everything. So, whether someone sees your cool product on their Instagram feed or finds it while browsing Amazon, they can buy it on the spot. It's all about making shopping easy for people and getting your brand seen by more eyes.

These integrations enable businesses to manage their product listings, inventory, and orders from a centralized location, ensuring consistency and efficiency across all channels. By leveraging these capabilities, businesses can engage with customers more effectively, streamline their sales processes, and ultimately drive higher conversions.

Customer Experience and Personalization

Personalization helps drive success by creating tailored shopping experiences that resonate with individual customers. AI-powered product recommendations leverage customer data to suggest items that align with their preferences and past behaviors.

Dynamic content allows ecommerce platforms to present relevant information and real-time offers as they adapt to the user's journey and make the shopping experience more engaging. Customer journey mapping helps with personalization by tracking and analyzing customer interactions across touchpoints so businesses can anticipate needs and deliver seamless, personalized experiences.

A promotional graphic with text

Comparing Ecommerce Platforms and Their Strengths

The major ecommerce platforms each offer distinct strengths tailored to specific business needs. Each platform has unique advantages and targeted industry applications that underscore their value in meeting diverse ecommerce demands:

Shopify

Shopify is tailored for small to medium-sized businesses and startups, offering an intuitive interface that simplifies the process of setting up and managing an online store. Its ease of use and scalability make it a great choice for businesses looking to expand without technical barriers.

Shopify has an extensive app ecosystem that provides a wide range of plugins and integrations that allow businesses to customize their stores. Its robust omnichannel capabilities let brands seamlessly integrate their online and offline sales channels for a cohesive customer experience across platforms, making Shopify particularly ideal for fast-growing direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands that need to quickly adapt and scale operations while maintaining a strong brand presence.

BigCommerce

BigCommerce meets the demands of mid-market and enterprise businesses that have complex needs. Its robust native B2B features cater to the intricate requirements of larger companies, offering advanced functionalities such as custom pricing, bulk discounts, and account management. BigCommerce stands out with its scalability and flexible APIs, allowing businesses to customize and integrate various systems to support growth and operational efficiency.

Additionally, the platform really steps up the game by letting you handle sales from different places all in one spot. It's handy because you can talk to more customers and keep things running smoothly without a headache. That's why brands that are starting to bloom love it so much. When they're ready to move on from the minor leagues, BigCommerce has all the cool features they need to keep up with more shoppers and sophisticated ecommerce demands, ensuring sustained growth and market competitiveness.

Adobe Commerce (Magento)

Adobe Commerce is an excellent choice for larger businesses with more complex ecommerce requirements. It includes unmatched open-source flexibility and many customization options. Its robust platform is tailored for enterprises that want complete control over their design and functionality, enabling them to create a fully personalized shopping experience.

Adobe Commerce also grows with your business. It doesn't matter if you're getting tons of visitors or if you've got a detailed product list; it keeps everything running smoothly. It's perfect for big companies that need an online store that can do a lot, like handle different languages, sort out tons of product details, and work well with other software. With Adobe Commerce, businesses can quickly adjust to whatever the market throws at them.

ROC Commerce

ROC Commerce is an ideal platform for businesses that require custom-built solutions to meet their unique ecommerce needs. Leading brands like WeatherTech, Ron Jon Surf Shop, OmniCable, and Coburn's trust ROC Commerce for its robust ecommerce solutions.

It’s designed to support complex, large-scale B2B and B2C operations with ease, offering seamless integrations and a consistent shopping experience across channels and devices. Its exceptional flexibility makes it a versatile choice for various business models. One of its key strengths lies in its built-in SEO and performance optimization features, which enhance visibility and site efficiency to drive better results. This makes ROC Commerce particularly suited for manufacturers, distributors, and wholesalers across multiple industries who need a tailored ecommerce solution that can handle complex demands.

OroCommerce

OroCommerce is a B2B ecommerce platform that addresses the unique needs of businesses with complex buying processes that require customized user experiences. Its strengths include comprehensive B2B features like multi-organization support, which allows businesses to manage different entities under a single platform, and multiple price list capabilities that cater to varied pricing strategies across customer segments.

OroCommerce's workflow automation streamlines intricate operations for improved efficiency by reducing manual tasks. This makes it advantageous for manufacturers, distributors, and wholesalers who need robust solutions to handle their multifaceted business processes.

WordPress and WooCommerce

WooCommerce is an ideal solution for businesses already utilizing WordPress. It’s a flexible, open-source ecommerce platform that stands out for its cost-effectiveness and extensive plugin library, providing unparalleled customization options to tailor the online store to specific needs. If you're running a small or medium-sized business and you've got a website packed with great content, you'll love how WooCommerce works with WordPress. It's a breeze to start selling stuff online because they fit together so well.

Salesforce Commerce Cloud

Salesforce Commerce Cloud is an exceptional ecommerce solution for large enterprises seeking integrated CRM, AI-driven personalization, and comprehensive omnichannel experiences. Its seamless integration with Salesforce CRM provides businesses with a unified platform that facilitates customer engagement through AI-powered insights, allowing for personalized shopping experiences that cater to individual preferences. This scalability supports global operations, making it a prime choice for large-scale B2C ecommerce businesses that require sophisticated customer interaction management.

Best Practices for Ecommerce Platform Selection

Here are the steps you should take to evaluate the platforms based on your business model and growth potential:

  1. Define Your Business Model and Goals
  2. Assess Scalability
  3. Evaluate Customization and Flexibility
  4. Examine Integration Capabilities
  5. Consider Costs
  6. Evaluate Support and Resources
  7. Align with Future Growth Potential

When you're picking an ecommerce platform, it's like choosing the right pair of shoes. You want something that's comfy and fits well right now, but also won't fall apart if you decide to run a marathon later. So, take your time, think about what you really need, and go for a platform that not only fits your immediate requirements but also supports strategic growth and innovation.

Let Americaneagle.com Help You Choose the Perfect Ecommerce Platform

Americaneagle.com is a leader in ecommerce website design and development, partnering with and implementing all of the top ecommerce platforms. Our extensive experience and expertise help us deliver tailor-made solutions across a variety of platforms for both B2B and B2C organizations.

Whether it’s integrating advanced features, optimizing user experiences, or ensuring scalability, we craft solutions that align with specific business objectives and market demands. For businesses at a crossroads of selecting or upgrading their ecommerce platform, Americaneagle.com offers unparalleled insights and guidance. And for already established ecommerce brands, we also offer a variety of digital marketing services so you can better target and reach your customers.

Contact Americaneagle.com today to explore how our expert services can transform your ecommerce vision into reality.

About the Author

Shawn Griffin

Shawn
Griffin

Shawn has been with Americaneagle.com since 1999 in a variety of roles. Currently, Shawn is part of our digital marketing and content team. In addition to editing and producing written company pieces, he produces copy for clients and he also helps to produce our radio and TV spots. He wants to make sure everybody knows that it’s truly a collaborative effort – between many, including the people he’s worked for during the past 20+ years!

Featured Posts