Artificial intelligence is integrating into nearly every facet of business and everyday activities. For search engine optimization, it is driving many efficiencies and reshaping strategies. AI tools have rapidly expanded, influencing industries worldwide, including digital marketing. Today’s business leaders must embrace AI-driven SEO to stay competitive in an ever-evolving search landscape.
In this episode of Modern Marketing Messages, our host welcomes SEO experts from Americaneagle.com, Kevin Williams and Harley Helmer. Their digital marketing team has been at the forefront of effectively integrating AI into modern SEO strategies. Kevin, a seasoned digital marketer, quickly adopted ChatGPT into his SEO planning, innovation, and execution with clients. Harley, also a career SEO pro, brings extensive industry experience and insights, and is a featured contributing author at Search Engine Land.
For captions, click "CC" within the video player. To read the transcript of this episode, click the transcript link within the description of the video on YouTube.
This blog explores AI’s impact on search, evolving SEO tactics, and how businesses can optimize, master, and scale their SEO strategies effectively.
AI’s Impact on Search: Reshaping the SERP Landscape
One way AI is transforming search is evident on search engine results pages (SERPs). AI-generated answers, called AI overviews (AIO) are often at the top of search results these days, pushing traditional organic listings and links further down. Google's AI overviews compile information from various sources to provide instant answers, reducing the need for users to click on website links. Additionally, AI has long played a role in Google’s ranking algorithms, analyzing vast amounts of data to deliver the most relevant results. With AI-driven search becoming the norm, businesses must refine their SEO strategies to remain visible. Optimizing for AI-generated snippets, improving content quality, and focusing on user intent are all important keys to maintaining a strong presence in this evolving landscape.
ChatGPT and Beyond: The Rise of AI-Powered Search
Despite popular proclamations that AI-powered tools like ChatGPT could replace Google, data suggests otherwise. A recent study found ChatGPT accounts for only 0.26% of total searches, with most queries focused on tasks like coding or writing—areas where Google continues to gain traffic. Google still dominates, with 14 billion daily searches, growing 21% year over year. While AI-generated overviews impact SERP click-through rates for informational searches, traditional SEO remains vital. Google continues evolving SERPs with more ads, shopping, and multimedia results, making visibility a steady challenge. SEO strategies must adapt, but AI alternatives are not eliminating Google search—at least not yet.
AI Overviews: A Threat or Opportunity for Organic Traffic?
AI-generated overviews have significantly affected website user acquisitions from organic search traffic, particularly for top-of-funnel informational queries. Google’s AI overviews now resemble traditional search results, pulling from the top-ranking sites, answering questions without the need to click a link from the results (zero-click searches). Additionally, AI responses are appearing in the “People Also Ask” section. Google is also testing an AI mode that removes organic listings altogether. While established sites may see a recent decline in traffic, savvy content creators still find success following SEO best practices. Structuring content with concise definitions, strong topical hierarchies, and subtopics remains crucial for well-targeted visibility. Businesses must stay attentive and agile as Google continuously refines AI integration, balancing content helpfulness with other ad-driven revenue strategies.
The Evolution of On-Page SEO in an AI-First World
AI has revolutionized on-page SEO, making it easier to generate content. A double-edged sword, it has also increased the risk of low-quality search results. At Americaneagle.com, AI is leveraged to refine keyword strategies, optimize content structure, and improve efficiency. By feeding AI tools with detailed research—such as refined keyword targets, competitor insights, and structured prompts—teams can scale SEO efforts while maintaining quality. AI also enhances automation for bulk updates, like optimizing thousands of headings or descriptions. Additionally, AI assists with coding challenges, enabling SEO professionals to refine structured data, CSS adjustments, and embedded elements, ensuring content remains optimized and competitive in an AI-driven digital marketplace.
AI-Enhanced SEO Tactics: Where It Matters Most
AI is transforming SEO with several key enhancements. Content generation works best for straightforward tasks, like creating schema markup or writing code, where minimal subjectivity is required. AI can also excel at internal linking by providing text variation, improving SEO impact. Additionally, using tools like Screaming Frog allows for crawling web pages and combining extracted data with prompts to generate unique content and optimize metadata at scale. This approach enhances on-page SEO, enabling more efficient, scalable processes for content creation, internal linking, and metadata updates, driving improved rankings and site performance.
Striking the Right Balance: AI vs. Human Oversight
Balancing AI with human oversight is crucial for generating high-quality SEO content. While AI can streamline tasks, such as generating descriptions or validating HTML, human review is necessary to maintain accuracy, especially in sensitive topics like health or legal advice. Over-relying on AI can lead to errors, as demonstrated by the infamous “eat rocks” example, where AI provided faulty advice. Industries like healthcare, finance, and many more require strict editorial processes and compliance checks. Best practices involve using AI to enhance efficiency, while ensuring that human creativity and oversight guide content to meet both brand quality and regulatory standards.
AI’s SEO Sweet Spot: Industries That Benefit the Most
AI-driven SEO is particularly beneficial for large websites with many variations, such as ecommerce and manufacturing sites. For example, product pages with slight differences—like variations in bolts or fasteners—can be efficiently managed with AI to generate unique descriptions. Local businesses and service-area companies, like plumbers, also benefit by creating location-specific pages for each city they service, ensuring better visibility on Google. However, human expertise is still necessary for nuanced industries where content must adhere to stricter compliance standards and maintain accuracy in sensitive areas. AI supports efficiency, but human oversight is crucial to ongoing success.
Pitfalls to Avoid: Common AI SEO Mistakes
A common AI SEO mistake is over-automating content creation, leading to generic pages that lack real value and usefulness. For instance, creating hundreds of pages without oversight can certainly harm your SEO performance, especially if the content is poorly generated. Another pitfall is neglecting search intent and audience engagement—AI-generated content must align with what users are searching for. Additionally, using AI tools without proper training or integration with SEO tools, like Ahrefs or SEMrush, can lead to subpar keyword research. It’s crucial to audit AI-generated content regularly, ensuring it meets quality standards and is optimized for SEO.
The Hidden Risks of AI-Driven SEO
Over-reliance on AI for SEO can create significant risks, particularly algorithm dependency. If Google pivots and penalizes AI-generated content, businesses heavily invested in AI could face ranking volatility that results in a dramatic drop in traffic. Ethical concerns also arise, as AI may generate misinformation or low-quality content, impacting brand reputation. Additionally, as AI evolves, search engines could introduce updates that further affect AI-driven SEO strategies. Companies must prepare for these potential changes by balancing AI with high-quality, human-driven content to ensure sustainable SEO success and mitigate future risks.
Blending AI with Brand Authenticity: The Content That Works
Blending AI with brand authenticity is crucial for standing out in an AI-saturated space. While AI can generate content efficiently, humanizing it with genuine brand engagement is essential. Businesses should focus on content like local events, charitable work, and team-building activities that showcase their personality and build a strong community presence. Videos, social media interactions, and storytelling help reinforce this authenticity. By maintaining a consistent brand voice across channels and adding unique, human-driven content, businesses can differentiate themselves, ensuring their brand resonates with audiences beyond AI-generated noise, helping to grow their visibility, credibility, and affinity.
The Future of SEO: What’s Next in the AI Era?
In the next 1 to 5 years, AI will empower users to easily create websites and applications, streamlining the process with templates and automation. This will further democratize website creation, making it accessible to anyone with an idea. AI will continue to drive SEO advancements by enabling more personalized experiences, improving voice search, and automating key tasks. As AI evolves, it will reshape how businesses approach SEO, making personalization more precise and creating new opportunities for automation. Preparing for these changes will be crucial for staying ahead in the rapidly advancing AI-driven SEO landscape.
Mastering SEO in the AI Age
AI is transforming SEO by enabling more personalized experiences, improving automation, and reshaping content creation. Businesses must adapt by balancing AI tools with human expertise, ensuring content remains authentic and brand-driven. Key steps for staying ahead include leveraging AI for efficiency, optimizing websites, and maintaining a strong brand presence across platforms. As AI continues to evolve, staying informed on advancements and preparing for future changes will be crucial. Ultimately, mastering SEO in the AI age requires harnessing AI’s power while preserving the creativity, quality, and thought leadership that authentic human expertise brings to the world.
Listen to Modern Marketing Messages Today!
Start listening to MMM on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Connect with:
- Modern Marketing Messages: Americaneagle.com // Twitter // Instagram // Facebook // YouTube
- Rex Paisley: LinkedIn
- Kevin Williams: LinkedIn
- Harley Helmer: LinkedIn
- Resources: Americaneagle.com Search Engine Optimization Services
Brought to you by Americaneagle.com, a digital marketing and web design company, Modern Marketing Messages discusses the latest and greatest in both online and offline marketing tactics, strategies, and trends. We take a deep dive into anything and everything marketing, speaking to the best and brightest minds in technology and marketing. Episodes will cover different areas of focus, from advanced SEO to paid search, personalization to influencer marketing, and everything in between.
Follow now.
